Ten stories from the Empire State

New York Horror Stories

Ten young people enter ten unsettling New York places in a fiction collection shaped by regional folklore, reported legends, and real locations. Start with the stories, then see where the book’s fiction and New York lore meet.

Ink illustration of storm clouds over Dunderberg Mountain and the Hudson River, with an empty kayak tossing in the waves.
Editorial ink illustration of a wooden boat dock on a quiet lake in Churchville, New York.

Read “The Blue Lady of Hidden Lake” Free

When seventh-grader Sophie Brennan investigates town rumors about a ghostly lady in blue along the lake, she uncovers town ledger records that reveal the real human history behind the ghost tale.

Read the complete Chapter 1 online with reviewed content notes. No email is required.

Start Reading

Ten Terrifying Tales

These are the exact story titles and locations in the New York collection. Published links lead to the free chapter or researched context; the remaining stories are available in the book.

  1. Churchville · Chapter 1 · Free online

    The Blue Lady of Hidden Lake

    Water-apparition and family history fiction. Read the documented history and lake lore.

  2. East Hampton · Chapter 2

    The Loom in the Loft

    Colonial mill and suspicion fiction. Read the 1658 Goody Garlick trial history.

  3. Fort Montgomery · Chapter 3

    The Heer of Dunderberg

    Hudson River storm goblin fiction. Explore Dutch river lore and highland squalls.

  4. Ovid · Chapter 4

    The Suitcases of Willard Asylum

    Preserved institutional history fiction. Examine the Willard suitcases and memory.

  5. Angola · Chapter 5

    The Light at the Lip

    Railroad trestle warning fiction. Read the 1867 rail disaster history.

  6. Lodi · Chapter 6

    The Seneca Lake Guns

    Finger Lakes acoustic booming fiction. Trace the mystery booms and geology.

  7. Upper Nyack · Chapter 7

    The Phantom Storm-Ship on the Hudson

    Tappan Zee ghost ship fiction. Read the maritime lore and river mirages.

  8. Montebello · Chapter 8

    The Spook Rock Dare

    Glacial erratic dare fiction. Explore Spook Rock’s geology and ghost lore.

  9. Lake George · Chapter 9

    The Lake That Keeps

    Adirondack deep-water fiction. Investigate colonial shipwrecks and cold waters.

  10. Ticonderoga · Chapter 10

    The Thing in the Warm Water

    Bulwagga Bay lake monster fiction. Examine two centuries of Champ accounts.

New York county map illustrating regional folklore settings.

The Legends Behind the Fiction

The collection uses real New York places and regional legends in fictional stories. That does not make every event in a story historical fact.

Start with the New York urban legends guide, then explore ten sourced companions covering every chapter subject: the Blue Lady, Goody Garlick, the Heer of Dunderberg, the Willard suitcases, the Angola light, the Seneca Lake Guns, the Hudson storm ship, Spook Rock, Lake George shipwrecks, and Champ.

Book cover for Hometown Horror Stories: New York.

Available now

Hometown Horror Stories: New York

Ten Terrifying Tales from the Empire State

Every New York town has a story it doesn’t like to tell out loud.

The Blue Lady who still walks the boarded dock at Hidden Lake in Churchville. A headless Heer stirring up a storm over the Hudson Highlands. A phantom ship beating upriver against the wind and tide off Upper Nyack. From a shuttered state asylum to the Finger Lakes, Lake George, and Lake Champlain, ten kids across the Empire State are about to learn that the legends their grandparents warned them about aren’t just stories. They’re still waiting.

Read all ten New York stories in the third Hometown Horror Stories collection by M. E. Sutherland.

View the Book on Amazon

Availability, format, and price are shown by the retailer.

For Adults Supporting Young Readers

The complete manuscript has been reviewed for suspense, threats, violence, death, language, and sensitive topics.

Use the chapter-by-chapter notes and editorial scare ratings to decide what suits an individual reader.

News for Parents and Adult Readers

Adults can join the Hometown Horror Stories list for the current free audio story and occasional book news.